$B?J2=O@@8J*3X$O5,HONQM}3X$NLr$KN)$D$+!)(J

$B0K@*EDE/<#!JL>8E20Bg3X!K(J

$BK\H/I=$G$O!"Fb0fAZ<7;a$,O@9M!VF;FA5/8;O@$+$i?J2=@8J*3X$X!W!J0J2e$N$h$&$JE@$K$D$$$F7!$j2<$2$F$_$?$$!#(J

$B#15,HONQM}3X$N4pHW$H$7$F$N?J2=O@@8J*3X(J

$B?J2=O@$+$i$NCN8+$O$O$?$7$F5,HONQM}3X$NLdBj$r9M$($k>e$GLr$KN)$D$@$m$&$+!#$b$A$m$s(J $B$3$l$K$?$$$9$k40A4$JEz$($rMW5a$9$k$3$H$O!"?J2=O@NQM}3X$,$h$&$d$/;e8}$K$D$$$?CJ3,(J $B$N8=:_$G$O2aBg$JMW5a$G$"$k$@$m$&$,!"?J2=O@$H5,HONQM}3X$r7k$SIU$1$k;n$_$r?J$a$F$$(J $B$/>e$G$O!"$9$/$J$/$H$b!V>-MhE*$K$OLr$KN)$D$+$bCN$l$J$$!W$H$$$&8+9~$_$OI,MW$G$"(J $B$k!#$7$+$7!"$3$N!V8+9~$_!W$H$$$&%l%Y%k$G9M$($k$3$H$K$7$?>l9g!"?J2=O@$O$o$l$o$l$K(J $B2?$r65$($F$/$l$k$3$H$,$G$-$=$&$@$m$&$+!)(J

$BFb0f;a$OBh#1#3@a$K$*$$$F!"$"$k$Y$-NQM}$r9M$($k:]$K!V?M4V$NG=NO$dF;FA$H$$$&1D$_$K(J $B4X$o$k2J3XE*$JCN8+!W$rL5;k$9$k$3$H$OIT9gM}$G$"$k$H$9$k!#$D$^$j!"!V!X$Y$7!Y$O!X$G(J $B$-$k!Y$r4^0U$9$k!W$H$$$&L?Bj$+$i$N5"7k$H$7$F!"$o$l$o$l$,$I$&$$$&F;FA$r;}$D$3$H$,(J $B$G$-$k$+J,$+$i$J$1$l$P$o$l$o$l$,2?$r$J$9$Y$-$+$bJ,$+$i$:!"2J3X$NCN8+$O$=$N=EMW$J(J $BMWAG$H$J$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#$o$?$7$OFb0f;a$N$3$NBg6Z$NO)@~$O7rA4$J$b$N$G$"$k$H;W(J $B$&!#$7$+$7!"$=$l$KB3$1$F!"Fb0f;a$O!"$+$l$N4T85r7oIU$-MxB> $B$^$:!"Hf3SE*>.$5$JLdBj$H$7$F!"$"$k$Y$-NQM}$N4pHW$OF;FA5/8;O@$,L@$i$+$K$7$?$h$&$J(J $BAG:`!V$G$7$+$"$j$(!W$J$$!"$H$$$&$J$I$NHs?J2=O@E*$JMW0x$,F;(J $BFA@-$N4pAC$H$J$j$&$k!JF;FA$r2DG=$J$i$7$a$k$H$$$&0UL#$G!K$3$H$rH]Dj$9$k$N$OFq$7$+(J $B$m$&$H$*$b$o$l$k!#(J

$B$7$+$7Fb0f;a$NN)>l$K$O$5$i$KBg$-$JLdBj$,$"$k$h$&$K$*$b$o$l$k!#$=$l$O!"5,HONQM}$N(J $B4pAC$H$7$F$O!"8=:_$N2f!9$,$I$&$$$&?4M}E*$JG=NO$r$b$D$+!"$H$$$&$3$H$,Bg;v$J$N$G(J $B$"$C$F!"$=$l$,$I$&$$$&M3Mh$G@8$8$?$+$H$$$&$3$H$,FslLL$G6&46$K4p$E$$$F9T0Y$9$k$3(J $B$H$rMW5a$9$k$N$O0UL#$,$J$$!"$H$$$&0UL#$G!"5,HOE*$JF;FA$r9M$($k>e$G$b$3$N$h$&$J8&(J $B5f$O;29M$K$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"?J2=O@$+$i$NCN8+$O$3$l$K$$$C$?$$2?$rIU$12C$($F$/(J $B$l$k$@$m$&$+!)$o$l$o$l$N6&46G=NO$N$"$ke$G$O!"?J2=E*%P%C%/%0%i%&%s%I$K$D$$$F$N>pJs$O$"$^$j4X78$,$J(J $B$+$m$&!#$b$A$m$s!"?J2=O@$N9M;!$+$i!"6&46G=NO$K$3$l$^$G;W$$$b$h$i$J$+$C$?$h$&$J@)(J $B8B$,$"$k$3$H$,L@$k$_$K=P$k$3$H$O$"$k$@$m$&!J8=:_$N?J2=O@$,$=$3$^$G$?$I$j$D$$$F$$(J $B$k$+$I$&$+;d$OHs>o$K2{5?E*$@$,!K!#$7$+$7$3$l$K$7$F$b!"?J2=O@$NLr3d$OF;FA?4M}3X$r(J $B$9$k>e$G$N:n6H2>@b$NDs<($H$$$&Fs

$B#26&46G=NO$dF;FA463P$O8=:_$N?J2=O@$G@bL@$G$-$k$+!)(J

$B$3$3$^$G$N5DO@$G$O!"6&46G=NO$d$=$l$rBg$-$JMWAG$H$9$kF;FA463P$,$I$N$h$&$K$7$F@8$8(J $B$F$-$?$N$+!"$=$N7k2L$I$N$h$&$JFC@-$r;}$D$N$+!"$H$$$C$?$3$H$,8=:_$N?J2=O@$G@bL@$G(J $B$-$F$$$k!"$H$$$&A0Ds$GOC$r$9$9$a$F$-$?!#$7$+$7!"?J2=O@$O$3$NLL$G$I$N$F$$$I@.8y$7(J $B$F$$$k$@$m$&$+!)Bh0lIt$G$N5DO@$K$h$l$P!"Fb0f;a$O%@!<%&%#%s$K$J$i$C$FF;FA463P$rB>(J $B$Nr7oIU$-MxB>r7oIU$-MxB>r7o$H$J$C$F$$$k$o$1$@$,!"$b$76&46G=NO$NB8:_<+BN$,?J2=O@$G(J $B$&$^$/@bL@$G$-$F$$$J$$$N$J$i!"Fb0f;a$N4T85p$H$7$F$N6&46G=NO$NFC@-$H$7$F!"8+JV$j$NF@$i$l$J$$Ajc324Q$KHs>o$KH?$9(J $B$k!#$3$NE@!"Fb0f;a$b0z$/%I%%!&%t%!!<%k$N!XMx8JE*$J%5%k!"Ajr7oIU$-MxB> $B$3$l$H4XO"$7$F$b$&0l$DIU$12C$($k$J$i$P!"$3$N$h$&$J6&46G=NO$,!VJ#9gE*?4@-!W$H$7$F(J $B$NF;FA463P$N=EMW$JMWAG$J$i$P!"F;FA463P$=$N$b$N$,>r7oIU$-MxB>e5-$N$h$&$J6&46G=NO$K4p$E$$$FF/$/$b$N$J$i$P!"8+JV$j$N(J $BF@$i$l$J$$AjN$9$k!"$[$s$N>/$7$@$1(Jtit for tat$B$h$j42MF(J $B$J@oN,$G$9$i4JC1$K:qH!K!#(J

$B$b$A$m$sFb0f;a$O$3$l$KBP$9$kH?O@$rMQ0U$7$F$$$k!#$9$J$o$A!"0U<1E*$K<+8JMx1W$rDI5a(J $B$9$k$3$H$O!"$o$l$o$l$N7W;;G=NO$N8B3&$J$I$+$i$$$C$F!"$+$J$i$:$7$b2f!9$N<+8JMx1W$r(J $B:GBg2=$7$J$$$N$G!"$`$7$m0U<1E*$K$O6&46G=NO$d$=$l$K4p$E$/F;FA463P$r?H$K$D$1$?$[$&(J $B$,NI$$$3$H$,B?$$!"$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$k!J$?$H$($P#2#6@a$J$I!K!#$7$+$7!"$o$?$7$,LdBj$K(J $B$7$F$$$k$N$O!"7W;;l9g$G$O$J$/!"$"$-(J $B$i$+$K8+JV$j$N$($i$l$J$$>l9g$K4X$9$kH=CG$G$"$k!#$b$A$m$s!"$"$-$i$+$K$_$+$($j$,$((J $B$i$l$J$$$H;W$($k>u67$G$b8+JV$j$,F@$i$l$k$3$H$O$"$k$@$m$&$,!"A4HLE*$K$O$=$&$$$&>l(J $B9g$K$=$Nr7oIU$-MxB>

$B#3F;FA@-$N:FDj5A$H$7$F$N3HD%$5$l$?>r7oIU$-MxB>

$B$"$k$$$O!"Fb0f;a$O!"F;FA@-$r3HD%$5$l$?>r7oIU$-MxB>MhM}2r$7$F$-$?0UL#$G$NF;FA@-$d$=$N4pAC$H$J$k6&46G=NO$r?J2=O@$N5DO@$GN"IU(J $B$1$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C$?$H$7$F$b!"$=$l$,H`$N5DO@$N7gE@$H$O8@$($J$$!#Fb0f;a$,!V0lDj(J $B$NHsF;FAE*$JG=NO$d798~@-$,$J$$$HF;FA$OIT2DG=$G$"$k$@$1$G$J$/!"F;FA$H$O$=$l$i$NG=(J $BNO$d798~@-$,B+$K$J$C$F:nMQ$9$k0l72$N8:>/$KBP$9$k8F$SL>$G$"$k!W!JBh#1#3@a!K$H8@$&(J $B$H$-!"H`$,G0F,$KCV$$$F$$$k$N$O$3$N$N $B$=$NH4$1Mn$A$F$7$^$&MWAG$H$O!"Cr7o$N0l$D$H$7$F5s$2$?;~!"$=$N4^0U(J $B$N0lIt$H$7$F!"!V$o$?$7$K$H$C$FAj]$rr7oIU$-MxB> $B$3$NIaJW2=$r=d$kLdBj$K4X$7$F!"Fb0f;a$O%P%$%"!<$NIaJW2=2DG=@-$N>r7o$r!"F;FA$NDj5A(J $B$H$$$&$h$j$O0lDj$N2ACMH=CG$r4^$`$b$N$H$7$FJ,@O$9$k!JBh#1#7@a!K!#$o$?$7$O$3$NJ,@O(J $B$K$OH?BP$7$J$$!#$7$+$7!"B?$/$N?M$,F;FA$NDj5A$H$_$^$,$&$^$G$KF;FA$K$H$C$F4pK\E*$G(J $B$"$jB3$1$F$-$?2ACMH=CG$,5_$($J$$$N$J$i$P!"$=$l$OFb0f;a$NF;FA@-$N:FDj5A!J:FDj5A$G(J $B$"$k$H$7$F!K$NBEEv@-$r5?$C$F$_$k==J,$JM}M3$K$J$k$@$m$&!#Fb0f;a$b$=$l$rM}2r$9$k$+(J $B$i$3$=9gM}E*$J9M;!$K$h$C$F!VIaJW2=!W$NMWAG$r>r7oIU$-MxB>e$K=R$Y$?=EMW$JE@$GIT==J,$G$"$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k!#(J

$B$3$3$G!"$3$N5DO@$OFb0f;a$N4T85o$K=EMW$J@.(J $B2L$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"$=$NJ,@O$N2aDx$GF;FA@-$=$N$b$N$,:FDj5A$5$l!":FDj5A$5$l$?$J$K$+(J $BJL$N$b$N$r4T85$7$F$_$;$k$H$$$&$N$G$"$l$P!"$=$NL%NO$OBgI}$K8:>/$7$F$7$^$&!#$3$N9`(J $B$G$o$?$7$,H?O@$7$F$$$k$N$O$=$&$7$?2DG=@-$G$"$k!#(J

$B#4!!!VJ82=E*@vN}!W$r$a$0$kLdBj(J

$B!!Fb0f;a$O!"$3$3$^$G$G=R$Y$?$h$&$J!V>r7oIU$-MxB>r7o$NBgH>$,4^$^$l$k!W$G$"$m$&$H<(:6(J $B$9$k!#$o$?$7$O!"F;FA$rJ82=E*$J$b$N$HB*$($k$3$H$K$OBg;?@.$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"$b$7$3$N(J $B;kE@$r$H$k$3$H$r5v$5$l$k$J$i!"$O$?$7$FFb0f;a$NBh0lIt$G$N>r7oIU$-MxB>o$K5?$o$7$/$J$C$F$/$k$H;W$&!#$3$NE@(J $B$r!"%I!<%-%s%9$N%_!<%`$N35G0$rMxMQ$7$J$,$i0J2 $B$h$/CN$i$l$F$$$k$h$&$K!"%I!<%-%s%9$OJ82=E*$KEAGE$5$l$k%"%$%G%"$d2ACM$J$I$r0lo$N0dEA;R$N?6$kIq$$$H:,K\E*(J $B$K0c$&$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k!J$3$NE@$K$D$$$F$O(J1988$BG/$N(JBiology and Philosophy no.3 vol. $B#2$G$N%O%k$HH`$NHcH=e$NMM$J@-e$K=R$Y$?$h$&$J%_!<%`$N@-r7oIU$-MxB>(J $B@\$NAj4X$,$J$$$H$$$&$3$H$O!"%I!<%-%s%9(J $B$d%"%/%;%k%m%C%I$,$D$+$&$h$&$J7+$jJV$7<|?M$N%8%l%s%^%2!<%`7?$N%b%G%k!J8DBN$NMxF@(J $B$N7W;;$K4p$E$$$F$"$k@oN,$NE,1~EY$rB,$k!K$,E,MQ$G$-$J$$$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#$?$H$((J $B$P!"$"$k<+8J5>@7E*$J9TF0$,B>$N8DBN$r46F0$5$;F1$8$h$&$J9TF0$KAv$i$;$k$H$-!"8DBN$H(J $B$7$F$NMxF@$OIi$G$b%_!<%`$K$H$C$F$NMxF@$O@5$H$J$k$3$H$,$"$k!#(J

$B$3$N;vBV$OF;FA$K$D$$$F$N?J2=O@E*$J5DO@$r9T$&>e$G$`$7$m4?7^$9$k$Y$-;vBV$G$"$k$h$&(J $B$K$*$b$o$l$k!#$3$3$O;d<+?H$N8+2r$rE83+$9$k>l$G$O$J$/Fb0f;a$N8+2r$K$D$$$FO@I>$9$k(J $B>l$G$"$k$N$Ge$G=EMW$J$N$O!"%&%#%k%9IB$NEAGE$HDC@E$r07$&(J $B1V3X$N%b%G%k$@$H$$$&$3$H$K$J$k!#$=$l$J$i$P!J%&%#%k%9$,8DBN$K$I$&$$$&Mx1W$r$b$?$i(J $B$9$+$H$$$&Ld$$$K$o$l$o$l$,$o$:$i$o$;$i$l$J$/$F$h$$$N$HN`HfE*$K!KF;FA@-$,8DBN$K$I(J $B$&$$$&Mx1W$r$b$?$i$9$+$H$$$&Ld$$$K$o$:$i$o$5$l$kI,MW$O$"$^$j$J$/$J$k!#$?$@$7!"DL(J $B>o$N%&%#%k%9$H0c$C$F!"F;FA@-$O0lC6=8CDA4BN$KL"1d$7$F$7$^$($P=8CDA4BN$K$H$C$F$=$l(J $B$J$j$NMx1W$r$b$?$i$9!J$3$l$,2+G.IB$J$I$H0c$$F;FA@-$,$$$D$^$G$?$C$F$b:,@d$5$l$J$$(J $BM}M3$G$"$m$&!K!#$b$7$3$l$,F;FA@-$N?J2=$r9M$($k>e$G@5$7$$%"%W%m!<%A$J$i$P!"Fb0f;a(J $B$,9M$($k$h$&$K>r7oIU$-MxB>]$G$O$J$$$@$m(J $B$&!#$7$+$7!"$3$l$O$I$A$i$+$H8@$($P35G0AuCV$NLdBj$H8@$&$h$j$OF;FA@-$H$$$&BP>]<+BN(J $B$NLdBj$G$"$m$&!#(J

$B:G8e$K!"$3$N!"F;FA$N1V3XE*%b%G%k$r9MN8$K$$$l$?$H$-!"Fb0f;a$N$$$&4T85l9g!"$3$N%b%G%k$K4p$E$/F;FA$N%$%a!<(J $B%8$O!JFb0f;a$N8@$&0UL#$G!KHs4T85E*$G$"$j$+$D7P83E*C55a$NBP>]$H$J$k$3$H$,==J,9M$((J $B$i$l$k!#$D$^$j!"$+$j$KF;FAE*2ACM$H$$$&%_!<%`$,B>$N2ACM$N%_!<%`$H40A4$KFHN)$NB8:_(J $B$G$b!"$=$NEAGE$N%a%+%K%:%`$r?4M}3X$d%2!<%`M}O@$NF;6qN)$F$rMQ$$$FC55a$9$k$3$H$O==(J $BJ,2DG=$@$m$&!#$3$N0UL#$G!"Fb0f;a$N9M$($k4T85$N2ACM4p=`$K$b$H$E$/Ez$($rM?$($&$k2DG=@-$O;D$5$l$F$$$k$+$i$G$"$k!#(J< p>

$B#5!!$*$o$j$K(J

$B0J>e!"HcH=E*$J%3%a%s%H$rJB$Y$F$-$?$,!"$o$?$7$,Fb0f;a$N4T85o$K;I7cE*$JF6;!$KIY$`$,!"K\H/I=$N@-3J>e$=$&$7$?L%NO$NItJ,$K$D$$(J $B$FB?$/$r8l$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$+$C$?$N$O;DG0$G$"$k!#Fb0f;a$NO@J8$r$-$C$+$1$K!":#8eF|K\(J $B$NNQM}3X3&$G$b$3$&$7$?O@5D$,@9$s$K$J$C$F$$$/$3$H$rK>$`

$BJ88%(J

$B1Q8l(J
1988 Biology and Philosophy, no.3 vol 2 ($B%G%t%#%C%I!&%O%k$N?J2=O@2J3XE/3X$r$a$0$k(J $BFC=8!K(J

$BF|K\8l(J
$B%"%/%;%k%m%C%I!"(JR.$B!!(J(1998)$B!XIU$-9g$$J}$N2J3X!Y>>EDM5G7Lu!"%_%M%k%t%!=qK<(J
$BFb0fAZ<7(J(1998,1999, forthcoming)$B!VF;FA5/8;O@$+$i?J2=NQM}3X$X!W!XE/3X8&5f!Y(J566, 567, 569$B!JM=Dj!K9f!J(Jhttp://www.bun.kyoto-u. ac.jp/~suchii/ev.ethics1.html$B$K$FF~ $B%I%%!a%t%!!<%k!"(JF. (1998)$B!XMx8JE*$J%5%k!"B>?M$r;W$$$d$k%5%k!Y@>EDMxDg!&F#0fN1H~(J $BLu!"Ap;W $B%I!<%-%s%9!"(JR. (1991) $B!XMx8JE*$J0dEA;R!YF|9bIRN4B>Lu!"5*0KT"20=qE9(J